Page 1 of 2 (24 messages)
[1] 2 ▶
#24
Robin September 9, 2026 at 6:11:51 PM
Your Website: https://harmless.monster

Hi, found you from the anti-AI webring, really enjoy your style and how you express yourself. My beliefs are pretty far afield, but you offer yours with eloquence and I enjoy reading your perspectives. Thanks for adding your voice to the indie web

Replied on: September 11, 2026 at 9:03:04 AM

Hi Robin, great to have you drop by and thanks for your kind words!

#23
eadiebug September 7, 2026 at 7:28:40 PM

No worries on the belatedness! I've been pretty busy myself, so thank you for the ping to let me know about your response. I really appreciate your thorough reply, you addressed not only my direct question but also some implicit questions/misunderstandings. Your exploration of the relationship between Shakespeare and Macbeth was especially helpful for understanding your perspective! I'm glad you brought up Brahman—that's exactly the sort of thing I was getting at. When I got back into spirituality, I was reading both the Book of Matthew and the Bhagavad Gita at the same time. I suppose my brain unified the concepts somewhat, which has led to me characterizing Jesus's teachings in a rather unorthodox way. I do think it's probably a safer bet in a lot of ways to build on the shoulders/starting axioms of giants as you're doing rather than playing spiritual Legos like me, ha! Regarding the Holy Spirit (HS), that's a fair point regarding Pentecost. Maybe creatures are born with the HS (as their own soul/spirit or a part of it)? In that case, Pentecost could occur with the activation of a latent HS rather than a new influx, but it would certainly appear to be new to those experiencing or witnessing it. This could also fit with an external God interpretation, with God possibly triggering the activation of the latent HS as the Gift of Pentecost. Since I'm suggesting the writers may not have had the whole story or may have misinterpreted it, this of course conflicts with Christian orthodoxy/revelation if you accept biblical word as total truth. My understanding of indwelling seems to have been incomplete/incorrect, but regarding indwelling of rocks, that reminds me of a quote I like: "God sleeps in the rock, dreams in the plant, stirs in the animal, and awakens in man." I interpret this from a bit of a panpsychist lens, with a universal consciousness existing in some form at the basest level of existence, maybe within or even below atoms. Increasingly complex organizations would then lead to likewise increasing awareness/attunement as the organism awakens to its own consciousness and eventually the universal consciousness. Returning to Pentecost, perhaps that's what occurred—tapping into that connection could have allowed them to utilize knowledge they hadn't learned directly. Perhaps what I was talking about was less indwelling and more differing levels of imaging, or awakenings to an inherent/latent HS. I hope all this makes sense. In any case, my thoughts on all of this are entirely fluid; I'm just having fun theologizing and trying to make sense of my own strange/mystic experiences. Also, added the Ed Winters book to my reading list. Thanks for the rec! Best wishes, EB

Replied on: September 15, 2026 at 9:37:20 AM

Hi eadiebug, Interesting point regarding this idea of a latent Holy Spirit. The thing that jumps out to me is that I think your view would separate the Holy Spirit from God. If the Holy Spirit is "latent" in everyone and then activated by God, would this then imply that the Holy Spirit is almost "natural" - like some kind of special physics - rather than supernaturally "from above". I think it's possible you're correct, but as you said this strays pretty far from an orthodox Christianity. With that said, the idea of a universal consciousness is not unexciting but I think it would take a lot of fleshing out to understand what we mean by that. Maybe an Avatar-esque or Force-like (like Eywa in Cameron's Avatar or the Force in Star Wars) "consciousness" that links all beings together. Or maybe a consciousness that emerges on a galaxy scale as opposed to our own brain scale. Both options would be interesting. I think the second would be as inaccessible to us as our thoughts are to a gnat. But the first option is probably closer to what you're describing. The issue for me is I don't really want to find the midichlorians of the Holy Spirit (I hope you have watched Star Wars or else that will make no sense!). I think this is a bit like trying to come up with a mathematical model of some physical phenomenon (my day job!), at heart though I find myself much more drawn to a more mystical approach. Essentially saying "it's a mystery and we should gaze upon it in wonder" rather than "it's a mystery and we should try and work out how it works". I think that's why in my original essay I tended to reach for a lot of metaphors: they help us look at the mystery with greater clarity without really telling us anything about how the mystery really works on a scientific level. I say all this, but then I did write two essays arguing in favour of physicalism (you may find them interesting) so in many ways I am quite happy to break things down into parts - it's more the extra-scientific step of supposing a "basest level of existence" that we can't detect scientifically and using it to explain supernatural phenomena (e.g. Thoughts (although that may be scientific as I argued in my essay), prayer, the Holy Spirit, the Eucharist etc.) that I am uncomfortable with. For these types of phenomena that can't be explained scientifically I think we can either suggest some kind of theoretical matter or mechanism, or simply leave them as a mystery. In some cases a theoretical matter/mechanism is useful, for example Miasma Theory was wrong but right enough to be useful, but in areas where we see no realistic hope of scientific explanation I prefer to leave it as mystery. Although I'm sure my view isn't the only "Christian" one, just look at the scholastics. I suppose what I am essentially saying is that Panpsychism makes me uncomfortable, it feels like a confusion or merging of science and spirit. That doesn't make it wrong, but equally I don't think I want it to be right. I think it would be a sad day if we one day discovered the "spirit" particle (let's call them "midichlorians";), like the final bit of mystery gone. Maybe that's not true, maybe it would re-enchant our culture; but I don't think that's been the trajectory of modern science. I have definitely heard people say that love is "just" brain chemicals - but what a disenchanted and sad view of a great mystery that is. I also wanted to touch on what you said about the Gospel writers not having the whole story or having misinterpreted it. It's an curious one because we often talk of the Bible as the "word of God", which is interesting because it's much closer to an Islamic idea. The Bible itself claims Jesus is the Word of God. Although I'm still developing my view, my general approach is twofold: Firstly the Bible (particularly the NT and with less accuracy the OT) is an authentic record of what was written by the original authors. Secondly Jesus commissioned the Apostles - who set up the early church - with everything they needed to know. Essentially then the NT authors would have had access to everything Jesus thought we needed. So although the whole truth may be more complex than the Bible presents, I think the Bible presents the whole truth that we need to know. Anyway, I think this is a really interesting discussion and the only reason I have written another long reply is that I enjoyed it. So any further thoughts are always welcome. Best, Discrete Ideas.

#22
eadiebug August 13, 2026 at 5:08:34 PM

I really appreciated your treatise "Imago Dei and Animal Ethics," especially the discussion about harmony as an active choice and veganism! I've actually moved towards a flexitarian and hopefully one day vegetarian diet for similar reasons. One thing I found interesting (from my admittedly non-traditional perspective) was this section: "A concern with my arguments so far may be that I have implied a kind of Pantheism; effectively saying that God is all. That is not the intention of my arguments and I do not wish to stray outside of an orthodox Christianity. Rather I am gesturing towards a kind of sacramental world view, one in which all creatures are visible signs of God's grace. Because they must be if they are a creation of God's grace." Is there a logical reason that you think God couldn't be all, other than that orthodoxy says/implies it isn't so? I ask not to argue or provoke, but because to me that limitation logically keeps God as something outside of us, a variant of the "man in the sky" that you say God is more than. To me, most (if not all) human spirituality/theology seems to try to communicate glimpses of this infinite, perfect whole that we can't conceive of in its totality—the alpha & omega, which when read as an example of merism conveys not just beginning & end, but also everything in between. I read that as all of the Universe, throughout all time. There's also the concept of indwelling, which I believe might be inherent to existence; i.e., Christ/God always lives within everything, perhaps as the holy spirit, and when we awaken to that truth we can draw strength, wisdom, and love from it. Considering that, I think I would agree that all creatures are visible signs of God's grace, but moreso because I believe God might dwell within all things as part of some sort of "universal consciousness" or "unified field." Anyway, apologies for getting all heretical in your guestbook. I hope that all makes sense, and I'm looking forward to your response. Also, congratulations on your wedding, best wishes for many happy years! :D

Replied on: September 1, 2026 at 12:22:14 PM

Hi eadiebug, I'm very pleased to hear that you read my essay and found it interesting. Thankyou for your comment! I hope you will excuse the somewhat belated reply. First of all it's always good to hear that someone has moved towards a flexitarian / vegetarian diet. Of course such a diet can be more or less challenging depending on where you live (even within the same country) but it's encouraging to hear. If someone is interested I always recommend (and if I know in person I loan my copy of) "This Is Vegan Propaganda: (And Other Lies the Meat Industry Tells You) - Ed Winters", it has a provocative title but I think it is well worth reading even if (actually especially if) you disagree with the authors conclusions. It's interesting that you picked up on my orthodoxy point. I think that in essence when I make an appeal, or restrict myself to, orthodoxy (in the lowercase sense) I am effectively saying that I don't want to work out everything again from first principles. I am restricting myself to the broadly agreed upon understandings and revelations that have come before. To address your question directly I don't know if their is a logical reason that God could not "be all" and as I understand it this would be a broadly Hindu understanding of "Brahman" (speaking very broadly and with a poor understanding of Hinduism). In a sense you could say that we have two broad understandings of God in human religion. The singular external God as understood by Christianity, Judaism, and Islam; and the God in all as expressed by Hinduism (and possibly other faiths). Of course I am speaking in vast generalities here and I must emphasise that I am no expert on Christianity, let alone other religions. I think then that if you think God is "one" or "all" really depends on your philosophical and revelatory starting point. In a sense these are your starting axioms. Personally as a Christian I have come to accept Christian revelation (for I think logical reasons, but I won't go into this now) and I think this quite clearly points to a God that is "one" (though also three) and that God creates all, rather than a God that is "all". Perhaps as a Christian I can say something like: God creates all things and therefore all things reflect God but God is still a separate creator. Much like saying Shakespeare writes Macbeth so Macbeth reflects Shakespeare but Shakespeare is not Macbeth. Perhaps I am saying that if we summed up all existence it would not be all that God is, that creation does not exhaust God. But I am not attempting to criticise your view of god "dwelling within all things", I don't think this is a strictly Christian understanding but I think it would be rather arrogant to think that Christian understanding perfectly describes God. But of course the indwelling of the Holy Spirit is Christian, but I'm not sure that we can say that the holy spirit is indwelt in all things (like say a rock). Rather I think the most natural reading of the gospels would be that the believer ordinarily receives the Holy Spirit at baptism. I don't think we can suggest that the Holy Spirit is already indwelling in all creation, presumably from the start of genesis, or else Pentecost (the apostles receiving the Holy Spirit) would not make a lot of sense - why should they need to receive something they already have? Maybe there is a difference between imaging God (like a sculpture images it's artist) and being indwelt by the spirit of God. None of this is to say that God is not the creating force and sustaining power behind all life (and all matter), but it is to say that for a Christian indwelling by the holy spirit is distinct from creation. Anyway thankyou for your comment and best wishes. All the best, Discrete Ideas.

#21
Hazel Russman June 29, 2026 at 1:27:17 PM
Your Website: hrussman.neocities.org

Thanks for following me. I don't actually understand this "following" business as I don't "do" social media, but I like your site and will enjoy exploring it. Like you I am an Anglican but more on the Evangelical side theologically. @duvarki: the key to Anglicanism is in the name! Uniquely this is not a denomination characterised by a theological position (if it were, then I agree that the 39 Articles would be its basis) but by its status as the default church of the English people. That's why it encompasses such a wide theological spectrum. Its distinguishing features for me are not particular beliefs but things like common sense, tolerance, respect for scholarship, and the right of national churches to manage their own affairs.

Replied on: June 30, 2026 at 12:25:01 PM

Hi Hazel, Thanks for your comment. I don't really do social media either, but I use the follow function as a way to see when sites I find interesting update. On the what is Anglicanism discussion I wrote a bit more about it on the 14th and 18th of May: https://discreteideas.neocities.org/pages/blog#may-14-2026 https://discreteideas.neocities.org/pages/blog#may-18-2026

#20
FlipSide May 27, 2026 at 6:50:00 PM
Your Website: flipside.nekoweb.org

Hello there, fellow Christian! :bouncey:

Replied on: June 3, 2026 at 10:20:31 AM

Hi FlipSide, Great to have you drop by!

#19
That One Rogue May 15, 2026 at 1:03:19 PM

Yeah, I was intending to reach a wider audience, trying to spread Gospel truth, but not force-feed it. I think that was a mistake looking back, or that I overcorrected there, and I should've hit more on the importance of following Christ's teachings and how that is how I got to the position I was arguing. I'm still learning. Thanks for helping me grow by giving me a good outside view of how my post could come across to those who didn't see the thought process behind it!

#18
That One Rogue May 14, 2026 at 8:29:10 PM
Your Website: https://that1rogue.xyz/blog/A-Response-to-good-critique

That took longer than expected. I finally finished my response to your post on Christ-centered manliness. It's a short read, and I may go back and update it with better points and/or wording, but I think its a sufficient response, especially given that writing is not my strong suit.

Replied on: May 15, 2026 at 9:12:58 AM

Really enjoyed reading your response. I think that we actually have a lot of agreement. I would say that your original article over emphasised physicality at the expense of virtue. My response, however, probably over emphasised virtue at the expense of the physical ability to put that virtue into practice (like having the physical skills needed to fix your neighbours roof). I also appreciate how you have clarified protection as encompassing community, church and neighbour rather than just the nuclear family which I think is the Christian vision we see put into practice in, for example, the book of Acts. I will update my article to send readers over to your response. Best of wishes and may Christ be with you, Discrete Ideas

#17
Dúvarkí May 13, 2026 at 1:17:43 PM
Your Website: https://duvarki.neocities.org

Hi! I pray you are doing well. I wanted to give a short reaction to your entry in Chronicles today. I do think the line between a "regular" Anglican and an Anglo-Catholic is a blurry one. Terminology within the English church has become so incredibly muddy as of late. I prefer to hold to the idea that "Anglicanism" is defined at bare minimum by its Articles of Religion, otherwise "Anglican" would be a fairly meaningless term. In that sense, an Anglo-Catholic is one whose material expression of faith is one which re-incorporates elements lost in the early English Reformation, like incense and bells. However, I am concerned with those whose Anglo-Catholicism is defined more by doctrine rather than expression, who deviate from the bare minimum reformed core of Anglican identity, and hold to Romish beliefs clearly rejected in the Articles. I feel that, at that point, one has ceased to be "Anglican" and become a Roman Catholic with an Archbishop in Canterbury rather than Rome. I say this not to somehow gate-keep Anglicanism herself, God forbid, for it is not man who may keep anyone from the Lord's Table. Rather, it is unhelpful when groups that clearly form their own separate identity contrary to the identity of Anglicanism take on labels associated with it. To those whose Anglo-Catholicism is indeed doctrinal, I am sincerely curious why many of them choose to stick to Canterbury rather than to turn to Rome; especially as the Articles call transubstantiation, purgatory, pardons, worshipping, and adoration, images as of reliques, and invocation of Saints "repugnant to the Word of God". Some indeed have, of course, like Chesterton. The peace of the Lord be always with you! - Dúvarkí

Replied on: May 13, 2026 at 2:22:44 PM

Hi Dúvarkí, I am well thankyou. A lot to explore in your comment. You draw an interesting distinction between doctrine and expression although I'm not sure it always works. For example incense or the way we decorate our churches are a form of expression but I think that expression is actually doctrinal or atleast theological. I recently attended a lecture on anglo catholic architecture & heard the phrase "our buildings are an act of worship". I'm not sure about the articles of religion as defining a "bare minimum" Anglican as I don't think Anglicanism has ever (successfully) enforced strict confesional adherance and has always left a wide degree of latitude available for interpretation.. It's something I will certainly explore in greater depth but I don't think that to be Anglican is to subscribe to some set of particular doctrines - definately not for the laity who have never been required to ascent to the 39 Articles. To offer a counter point to defining Anglicanism through the Articles. I would say that Anglicanism is the English national Church and those global Churches whose heritage is essentially derived from English tradition despite local developments. I'm curious if you think that someone who believes in transubstantiation could (or should) continue to call themsleves anglican? I do. But I am also comfortable with someone who takes a memorialist view continuing to call themselves anglican. Basically I take quite a wide view on what are acceptable views/beliefs - although I get that there is a difference between a lay persons theological (or lack of) views and those permisible for clergy. You have given me a lot to think about though and I am very glad to get your feedback. I will certainly be exploring these areas in more detail. The peace of the Lord be always with you! Discrete Ideas

#16
eadiebug May 7, 2026 at 1:47:38 AM

All good on the slow reply! I think I messed up the Tolstoy link anyways... you can find it on Project Gutenberg. That book actually addresses some similar themes to your masculinity essay, particularly that complete nonviolence as commanded in the Sermon on the Mount is difficult but imperative for those that claim belief in Christ. Speaking of your essay, I appreciated your deconstruction of masculinity and emphasis on it being more than material provisioning, that truly does set the bar too low and has the potential for great harm. Under that framework, worth is measured via productivity instead of being inherent to each person, and to some extent it discourages/damages the social bonds that give life meaning ("Cat's in the Cradle" type stuff, providing materially overshadows providing emotionally). I believe Christ points towards a vision of humanity where we're only concerned with whether we're being as loving as possible, not whether something/someone is masculine or feminine (or any other judgements). I'm looking forward to your essays on atheistic interpretations of the resurrection and the ordination of women! I'd also be curious to hear about what being an Anglo-Catholic means to you personally, i.e. why that and not any other denomination? Though I know that's probably a big question lol!

Replied on: May 11, 2026 at 2:25:15 PM

Hi Eadiebug, I really appreciate your thoughtful and kind comments! I hope to get an article out on womens ordination in the next few weeks (I actually posted about it in my Chronicles) section today. And yes I will be definately exploring anglicanism and anglo-catholicism in many more of my posts. Thanks, Discrete Ideas

#15
girl ben Elohim May 1, 2026 at 4:41:09 PM
Your Website: https://girlbenelohim.faith

~girl waz hare~ :love:

#14
Chili April 30, 2026 at 7:01:46 PM
Your Website: https://chillybeans.nekoweb.org/

Hello Discrete Ideas, I came to check out your website and wow what an interesting place to be. I enjoyed reading through your posts and seeing your perspective on current topics. Your post "On Manhood: A Christocentric Vision" definitely deserves its spot in the Best Posts section as it offers great critique and perspective on a topic that I've seen often taken from one extreme to another on the internet. I look forward to coming back to look at your website in the future!

Replied on: May 1, 2026 at 8:02:03 AM

Hi Chilli, I'm really glad you like the site and enjoyed reading my perspectives. The post on Manhood is definately the work I am most proud of here. I'm busy with work & life for the next couple of days but when I get a chance I'll add your website button to my stamp collection page.

#13
That One Rogue April 17, 2026 at 2:49:27 PM
Your Website: https://that1rogue.xyz

Well that was... convicting. I thoroughly enjoyed reading your response. I'll probably write a followup post to my original correcting it in places. Would you mind if I quoted your post in places as something that I'd be responding to?

Replied on: April 18, 2026 at 10:25:20 AM

I’m really glad to hear that you enjoyed reading my article and absolutely, you’re very welcome to quote my post. I think that as Christians it’s very helpful to engage with and hopefully build upon each others ideas like this. If you would like to discuss anything in more detail do feel free to email me.

#12
That One Rogue April 14, 2026 at 5:04:55 PM
Your Website: https://that1rogue.xyz

Responding to your comment in my guestbook, feel free to critique/respond to my blog post! I'm not sure it's where I want it, but I wanted another post up and it was good enough. I'll probably refine it here soon-ish.

Replied on: April 15, 2026 at 2:42:30 PM

Hi! Thanks for getting back to me. I had a draft written yesterday which I have now replaced with another half written draft and is turning out to be quite a long essay on the subject of masculinity from a Christian perspective. I'm using quotes from your essay as I think they provide a really good summary of some ideas that I want to challenge. When I am done and my post goes live I'll drop a message on your guestbook.

#11
Anonymous March 26, 2026 at 7:41:46 PM
Your Website: that1rogue.xyz

Howdy friend! Love the vibe! Came from the webring

#10
eadiebug March 26, 2026 at 3:57:34 AM

I appreciate seeing another STEM person interested in theology! I've been into it recently after reading Tolstoy's Kingdom of God Is Within You and Helen Keller's My Religion. I enjoyed "When Matter Starts Thinking" and look forward to reading more of your theological perspectives :) also, the ornamental initials on your main page are cool!

Replied on: April 15, 2026 at 2:49:24 PM

Hi I am really glad you found my site. Sorry for the slow reply, I think because of the URL's your post wasn't auto approved. I haven't read either of those books so thankyou for the recomendation, I'll be sure to check them out. I hope you do come back and check out future posts, I am writing several different articles right now and hope to have a piece up about masculinity within the framework of the teachings of Christ soon. All the best, Discrete Ideas

Page 1 of 2 (24 messages)
[1] 2 ▶